After the Allies were successful in defeating Germany in World War Two, trials were held in the German city of Nuremberg to determine who in the German government and military were guilty of war crimes. Many pled “Not Guilty” on the basis that they were “Just following orders” which had been given them by their superiors. Those attempts failed, on the basis that no one is morally or legally required to do things which are manifestly wrong or illegal.
Now, we have a case where United States Marine Corps Lt. Colonel Stuart Scheller, shown above, is being held in solitary confinement in the “Brig” at Camp Lejeune, NC. What crimes did he allegedly commit which would justify such severe measures, even before he was given a pre-trail hearing and allowed to secure legal council? Now we know.
Scheller is accused of the following offenses under the UCMJ: Article 88: Contempt toward officials, Article 90: Willfully disobeying a superior commissioned officer, Article 92: Failure to obey an order, and Article 133: Conduct unbecoming an officer and a gentleman. Let’s examine those in order.
Contempt towards officials:
I guess he might be guilty of that, but he is joined by tens of millions of his fellow citizens, who were appalled at the actions taken by our military leaders, from the Commander in Chief on down, who unbelievably botched the withdrawal from Afghanistan. Eighty BILLION dollars worth of military equipment, much of it sensitive in nature, abandoned to the Taliban terrorists? Refusing to hold Bagram Airbase as the center of the evacuation efforts, and allowing the Taliban to maintain the security zone around the Kabul airport? Creating the conditions that allowed an ISIS suicide bomber to kill over a hundred people just inside and outside of the barbed wire at the airport, 13 American servicemen and women among them? That isn’t behavior worthy of contempt?
Willfully disobeying a superior commissioned officer:
I guess that was when he didn’t comply with what was essentially a questionable “gag order” from the Pentagon. Bill Clinton did this when he signed Executive Order13039 on March 9, 1997. That prohibited members of the military from telling what they knew about the crash of TWA 800 the previous July. The reason given for that E.O. was “National Security”, but since the FBI and NTSB had already stated the crash was caused by a mechanical malfunction, what national security issue was involved? We don’t know that to this day. In the case of Colonel Scheller, the higher ups, all the way to the Oval Office, didn’t want to be embarrassed, or worse, held accountable.
Failure to obey an order:
As in the case of the Germans at Nuremberg, you are not required to obey an order you feel is immoral or illegal. Colonel Scheller knew he would have to defend his actions, but he is a man of character, and was willing to take that chance. I wish there were more like him, both in the military and in the halls of Congress.
Conduct unbecoming an officer and a gentleman:
That is the most laughable of all these charges. Is it “unbecoming” to speak out when you see an example of gross incompetence, which has needlessly cost the lives of American military members, and put the lives of American Citizens and allies at risk? The “woke” culture which has been allowed to infect our military by the Commander in Chief, Secretary Austin, General Milley, General McKenzie and other high Pentagon officials puts this nation at risk. Our adversaries don’t give a damn about transgender quotas, pregnant fighter pilots, or understanding “White Rage”. They are concerned with defending their countries interests and dominating potential enemies. As Rush Limbaugh was fond of saying: “The job of the military is to kill people and break things!” An oversimplification to be sure, but the military isn’t there to “Nation Build” or anything else, but effectively defend this country.
I urge everyone who reads this to contact their Senators and Congressional Representative, and Demand that Lt. Colonel Scheller be exonerated of all charges, released, and if he so desires retire from the military with all his hard earned rights intact after nearly two decades of honorable service to this country. Anything less will be a travesty of justice.